Date
Attendees
- Vimal Begwani
- Seshu Kumar Mudiganti
- Xin Miao
- Dongho Kim
- Fei Zhang
- John Quilty
- Prabhu Balan
- Swaminathan Seetharaman
- yaoguang wang
- Oskar Malm
- Sandeep Shah
- Fernando Oliveira
- Melanie Sater
- Marci Haas
- Gerard Hynes
- Fari Behi
- Raghavan Subramanian
- N.K. Shankaranarayanan
DISCUSSION ITEMS LOG
| Ctgry | Item | Who | Notes |
Pltfm | PLATFORM TOPICS: Controller to NF Association | R5/R6 Topic See Slides Nov 6, 2018. Development of Controller to NF assignment association S/W. CDS, VF-C, APP-C, SDN-R, SDN-C; will the CCSDK "merging" of controllers happen in R6? | |
| Pltfm | PLATFORM TOPICS: Data Persistency, RunTime DB | STATUS: Work for RunTime DB completed, not merged in R4 Dan Timoney moved to R5, one Jira for RunTime DB. One issue about merging. ONAP code added can take a test ONAP deployment to have the ConfigDB work. USE CASE REALIZATION MEETING (Notes 2019-01-30) U/C Cross-Interaction, Persistency | |
| Pltfm | PLATFORM TOPICS: Controller LCM API Evolution | Goals (Architecture Evolution)
Present at the Arch S/C Apr 9 (Tue) second presentation. | |
| Use Cases | USE CASE/5G: RAN (ORAN-3GPP) Standards harmonization with ONAP |
Use Case WIKI: MOBILITY STANDARDS HARMONIZATION WITH ONAP | |
| Use Cases | USE CASE/5G: Licensing Management | New U/C added to the 5G Use Cases for Licensing Management Use case Wiki: LICENSING MANAGEMENT (Oct 8 2019) Arch Samuli presented on Licensing Management. Object development. Modeling S/C. Modeling work: ONAP R6 Modeling High Level Requirements | |
| Use Cases | USE CASE/5G: OOF / SON / PCI | PoC for December 2019? SDN-R south-bound NetConf I/F w/ model and also integration with Runtime DB work. | |
| Use Cases | USE CASES: BBS U/C Evolution | BBS Evolution - Slide set linked in R6 proposed U/C. List of proposals & functional requirements.
| |
| Use Cases | USE CASES/5G: PM Dictionary/FM MD GUI | FM META DATA & PM DICTIONARY in R5 | |
| Use Cases | USE CASES/5G: PNF S/W Upgrade | PNF software upgrade in R6 Frankfurt | |
| Use Cases | USE CASES/5G: Preonboarding/Onboarding | PNF PREONBOARDING / ONBOARDING in R5 | |
| Use Cases | USE CASES: IoT Service Creation | IoT Create Services on 5G June 19, 2019 | |
| Use Cases | USE CASES: Modeling gNB/5G RAN | Align & harmonize information models to ONAP model and ONAP internal information & data model: ETSI SOL001 ... 007 with ONAP internal Model, PNFD modeling (Model S/C), 5G Model (3GPP, RAN), ORAN (WGs, RAN), Open ROADM (reconfig optical add/drop multiplexer, Optical), ONF (Optical), ISOMII (Optical), OTCC (Optical transport config & control) | |
| Use Cases | USE CASES: 5G NRM (Network Resource Model) Configuration | yaoguang wang | June 2019 LFN DDF, titled as '5G Provisioning management service to NRM' (Oct 9 2019) Presented at CDS team and discussed with Yuriy and Seshu; presented at Resource Modeling S/C. Slides will be updated and re-presented. 5G Network Resource Model (NRM) Configuration in R6 Frankfurt |
| Arch | Architecture S/C PNF POB/OB Flow | Arch S/C Information Flows: Draft ONAP Information Flows New Information flow for Preonboarding/Onboarding xNF packages/resources. | |
| TSC | TSC: PoC Definition | POC definition | |
| TSC | TSC/USE CASES: Test Automation Progress | Use Case Test Automation Action Items: Use case subcommittee to reach the Dublin use case owner to provide the following information. what's the current percentage of testing automation regarding your use case and functional requirements; what will be the plan to be 100% and constraints (resources availability etc.) | |
| R6 Frankfurt / M1 | Need the U/C teams to fill out the Dev. Impacts. More Generalized Use Case Template (discussed w/ Model team): | ||
Frankfurt Release Requirements
KEY PRESENTATIONS & OVERVIEWS & RECORDINGS
List of U/C Realization calls from R6 U/C Wiki: Release 6 (Frankfurt) proposed use cases and functional requirements
| DATE | TOPIC | PRESENTER | DESCRIPTION |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Controller LCM API Evolution |
| |
| May 1, 2019 | A&AI GraphGraph Visualizer | Visualizer for A&AI Model Layout | |
| May 8, 2019 | A&AI Model Browser, Sparky | A&AI developer Model Browser to navigate and viewing attributes, object types & edge view Recording & Slides: Use Case Realization Call: May 8, 2019 | |
| May 15, 2019 | A&AI Run Time Browser (Sparky) | A&AI Run-Time Browser | |
| May 22, 2019 | Edge Automation Overview & Discussion | Central & Distributed Edge ONAP configuration. Topics include: Onboarding, Instantiation, Edge Orchestration, A&AI, Architecture, Work-flows, Multi-Tenancy | |
| May 29, 2019 | Modeling, Use Case & Arch S/C Way of Working | Model S/C (Sub committee) contributions page: Modeling sub-committee Contributions | |
| Jun 5, 2019 | Use Case slides for Dev. Forum | Use Case Realization Call: June 5, 2019 | |
| July 10, 2019 | R6: PNF Software Upgrade | ONAP Read the Docs/R4 Announcements WIKI: PNF software upgrade in R6 Frankfurt Overview & Presentation | |
| July 24, 2019 | R6: OOF/SON PCI Use Case Demo | NK Shankar | OOF / PCI / SON Use Case Discussion and Overview |
| 5G NRM Configuration U/C Overview | yaoguang wang | 5G NRM (Network Resource Model) Configuration U/C Overview & Presentation |
| ORAN Standards Harmonization | ORAN Standards Harmonization U/C Overview & Presentation | |
| Modeling S/C guidelines & Use Case Interactions | Modeling S/C Process Wiki: Proposed ONAP Release Process Updates for Information and Data Modeling with Use Case Tracking Template and Use Case Template R6 Modeling Req Plan wiki: ONAP R6 Modeling High Level Requirements | |
| Licensing Management Overview | Introduction of Licensing Management in R6 | |
| SDC & R6 Use Case Impacts Discussion | Ofir Sonsino | Discussion with SDC PTL Ofir w/ the Use Case Teams and SDC commitments. See the summary Table for SDC impacting Use Cases. |
| VID & R6 U/C Discuss | Use Case Teams | Discussion with VID PTL (Ittay Stern) for R6 Use Case Impacts discussion and commitments for VID impacting Use Cases Preparing slides for Use Cases at the Technical Conference Antwerp (for 5G/PNF use cases) |
| A&AI & R6 Use Case Impacts Discussion | Discussion with A&AI PTL (Jimmy Forsyth) and Chandra Cinthala for R6 A&AI Use Case Impacts discussion and commitments. | |
| DCAE & R6 Use Case Impacts Discussion | Vijay Venkatesh Kumar | Discussion with DCAE PTL (Vijay Kumar) for R6 Use Case Impacts discussion and commitments for DCAE impacting Use Cases |
| M1 U/C discussion | Use Case Teams | R6 M1 Deadline (Oct 10 2019) M1 Checklist: Deliverables for Planning Milestone Checklist Template READ THE DOCS: http://onap.readthedocs.io/en/latest/guides/onap-developer/developing/index.html > USER GUIDES > Verified Use Cases and discussion with A&AI (James Forsyth ) continuing discussion from Sept 25. Network Slicing has two proposals in R6 (LIN MENG CMCC and Swaminathan Seetharaman ). Need to align the two proposals and present at Use Case S/C meeting (Alla G.) and TSC and Architecture next week Oct 14. |
| PoC Planning & Discussion | Tracy Van Brakle | Combination Plugfest & PoC 1st week of December bringing together subset of ONAP modules as SMO (svc mgmt orchestration) layer w/ other artifacts from ORAN S/W (LF). LF will publicize. Planned June 2020. Co-Demo discussion Nokia & Ericsson: Plug Fest Planning Discussion Oct 28, 2019 |
| RunTime Config DB (Data Persistency) | Discussion of the RunTime DB Use Case in R6 Frankfurt which introduces a Common Service Data Layer for a data lake to store configuration and operational parameters. Component & Flows: ARC RunTime DB Component Description - R6 Frankfurt | |
| OOF & R6 Use Case Impacts Discussion | Shankar PN | Discussion with OOF PTL (Shankaranarayanan Puzhavakath Narayanan ) for R6 Use Case Impacts discussion and technical details for OOF impacting Use Cases |
| SO & R6 Use Case Impacts Discussion | Discussion with SO PTL (Seshu Kumar) for R6 Use Case Impacts discussion and commitments. | |
| PoC Planning & Discussion | Tracy Van Brakle | Sync up on the Dec 5, 2019 ORAN/ONAP PlugFest & Demo |
| Network Slicing | CMCC-Huawei-Tencent & Wipro-ATT-Amdocs joint Network Slicing proposal | |
| No Meeting | No Meeting | |
| MDONS | Xin Miao | Presentation and discussion of Multi-domain Optical Network Services |
| Ctlr & R6 U/C Impacts | Dan Timoney | Discussion with Controller (APP-C, SDN-C) PTL (Dan Timoney) for R6 Use Case Impacts to Controller project. A technical discussion, Q&A, and U/C analysis. |
| No Meeting | No Meeting | No meeting end of December due to Holidays & Vacations |
| x, 2019 | Discussion of Use Case Template for R7 | Filling out, describing and creating the Wiki for a Use Case | |
| x, 2019 | Release Manager Discussion | David McBride | Discussion with David McBride of the Linux Foundation, the R6 Release Manager regarding practices, wiki page updates, Jira dashboard and what is a use case? |
SO USE CASE IMPACTS FOR R6
Frankfurt Release Requirements
| PNF / Preonboarding Onboarding | Wiki Page: PNF/VNF PREONBOARDING / ONBOARDING in R6 Frankfurt SUMMARY: No Impact |
| PNF / Plug and Play | Wiki Page: PNF PLUG and PLAY in R6 Frankfurt Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact Frankfurt Release Requirements : Indicates Impact WIKI:
SUMMARY: E#3a: Change to the onboarding (definition) of the BPMN workflow. (SO-1838) E#3b: Migrate existing workflows to existing building blocks. (SO-1838) ACTION: Seshu Kumar Mudiganti create a new story to make it more explicit SO-1838 - Getting issue details... STATUS (Task) |
PNF / PNF Software Upgrade using direct Netconf/Yang interface with PNF REQ-84 - Getting issue details... STATUS | Wiki Page: PNF software upgrade in R6 Frankfurt Frankfurt Release Requirements : Indicates Impact This is one of the PNF upgrade scenarios. Also includes development of some common functionality used by the other PNF upgrade scenarios. Use case with all scenarios was presented at the SO meeting. Question (Seshu) regarding resources/workforce how many people will be working on this? joint commitment Ericsson & Huawei. Multiple people working on the U/C but don't know how division of labor yet. Want people E2E, from coding through integration. We have seen in SO is lacking in integration/test. When committing resources would be nice to have E2E commitment. Would like to have post M4 (RC0-RC2) support. Expectation: Need to plan for different types of testing/bug fixing. Fwd'd to team. Question Seshu: asking how many people? Answer: not defined, there is a team expect enough resources. Seshu: problem when moving resources across teams, tech different and expectations different. expertise is insufficient across projects. To finish this need to identify people asap; Oskar: there is one experienced person with SO. yaoguang wang new API impacts in SO. Talked with Zu Qiang (Ericsson) in SO will provide new PNF custom W/F API. North-bound API to trigger PNF work-flow. Use existing W/Fs? Same principle as for VNFs. Look at the url will see PNF instead of VNF. CM requirements for PNF S/W upgrade. There is already W/F API for VNF. Propose to add a NEW API for PNF. Will discuss before M2. SO-2071 - Getting issue details... STATUS WIKI:
SUMMARY: - SO-2070 - Getting issue details... STATUSSO-2071 - Getting issue details... STATUS SO-2072 - Getting issue details... STATUS SO-2073 - Getting issue details... STATUS SO-2091 - Getting issue details... STATUS SO-2090 - Getting issue details... STATUS SO-2089 - Getting issue details... STATUS |
PNF / Enable Schema Update once PNF software is updated REQ-88 - Getting issue details... STATUS | Wiki Page: PNF software upgrade in R6 Frankfurt There is no SO impact for this requirement in Frankfurt. |
PNF / Enhancement on PNF Software Upgrade with EM with Ansible REQ-53 - Getting issue details... STATUS | Wiki Page: PNF software upgrade in R6 Frankfurt Frankfurt Release Requirements : Indicates Impact This is one of the PNF upgrade scenarios. SO development committed by Huawei. |
PNF / PNF Software Upgrade with EM with Netconf REQ-96 - Getting issue details... STATUS | Wiki Page: PNF software upgrade in R6 Frankfurt Frankfurt Release Requirements : Indicates Impact This is one of the PNF upgrade scenarios. SO development committed by Huawei. |
PNF / Configuration with NETCONF/ Secure Communication between xNFs and ONAP REQ-76 - Getting issue details... STATUS | Wiki Page: Configuration with NETCONF in Frankfurt/R6 Test only, no SO development in R6 for this feature. For integration e2e test case, the latest PNF workflow will be used. It is possible that this WF will be updated by other release requirements during R6 development. |
| 5G / 5G Service Modeling | Wiki Page: 5G RAN SERVICE MODELING & DEFINITION in R6 Frankfurt The platform information model may impact SO as SO consumes the model. SUMMARY: Need to investigate if model changes will impact SO consumption of the model. Ben will send Seshu presentation made to the modeling sub-committee. |
5G / Bulk PM / PM Control REQ-129 - Getting issue details... STATUS | Wiki Page: 5G Bulk PM in Frankfurt/R6 Frankfurt Release Requirements : Indicates Impact WIKI: Workflow shall update status attribute in AAI when the VNF/PNF instance has been fully instantiated. Will have dependency/connection. For PNFs there might be a gap. - QUESTION: (Marci Haas) This is a Use Case in December 5, 2019 to be demoed, are we on track? ANSWER: the new functionality will not be in the December Demo.
SUMMARY: There might be a dependency on the SO refactoring (See PnP U/C Epic #3a/#3b) SO-2399 - Getting issue details... STATUS |
| 5G / PM Dictionary | Wiki Page: FM META DATA & PM DICTIONARY in R6 Frankfurt SUMMARY: No Impact |
| 5G / 5G FM Meta Data | Wiki Page: FM META DATA & PM DICTIONARY in R6 Frankfurt SUMMARY: No Impact |
| 5G / OOF SON (PCI) | Wiki Page: OOF (SON) in R5 El Alto, OOF (SON) in R6 Frankfurt SUMMARY: No Impact |
| 5G / E2E Network Slicing | Wiki Page: NETWORK SLICING PoC in R6 Frankfurt (Obsolete) Frankfurt Release Requirements : Indicates Impact WIKI: Original scope has undergone some changes, Swaminathan Seetharaman will discuss with SO the impacts.
SUMMARY: Impacts SO-2281 - Getting issue details... STATUS (Epic)need to create additional Jira, ... there is an Epic, and will need to create a story. |
5G / RAN ORAN 3GPP Standards Harmonization | Wiki Page: MOBILITY STANDARDS HARMONIZATION WITH ONAP SUMMARY: No Impact |
| 5G / Runtime Config DB , Data Persistency U/C | Wiki Page: 5G CONFIGURATION (RunTime DB) Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact WIKI: Wiki Indicates No Impact SUMMARY: - |
| 5G / NRM CM w/ RESTful HTTPS | Wiki Page: 5G Network Resource Model (NRM) Configuration in R6 Frankfurt Frankfurt Release Requirements : Indicates Impact WIKI:
SUMMARY: Need some additional offline meetings with yaoguang wang |
| 5G / Licensing Management | Wiki Page: LICENSING MANAGEMENT SUMMARY: No Impact, Modeling & architecture work only for R6. |
| SERVICE RESOLVER | Wiki Page: Service Resolver Seshu has discussion w/ the U/C team. Know the impacts. SO has impact but it is not in scope for R6; SO changes will be in a future release. SUMMARY: changes Out of scope for R6 |
| SCALING | Wiki Page: Scaling Use Case (Frankfurt) Frankfurt Release Requirements: Indicates Impact WIKI:
SUMMARY: Wiki indicates Seshu has committed. No Jira created yet. Yuriy Malakov may have already created tickets for this (check) Benjamin Cheung Seshu Kumar Mudiganti Scale out with CDS Actor JIRA is SO-2316 - Getting issue details... STATUS |
| Mobile Service Chaining & Service Selection | Wiki Page: MOBILE SERVICE CHAINING SUMMARY: - |
| BBS | Wiki Page: BBS Broadband Service Use Case (Frankfurt) Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact WIKI: Needs Investigation. Wiki page needs work. SUMMARY: Needs Investigation. Seshu says there is no commitment right now for this U/C Potential outage Chaker Al-Hakim . Scope is undefined. Not decided what will happen in R6 release. Update from David Perez Caparros: BBS use case will focus on bug fixes and documentation in R6, as reported during the last F2F use case subcommittee meeting in Antwerp. |
| CCVPN | Wiki Page: CCVPN Use Case in Frankfurt Release Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact Frankfurt Release Requirements: ELINE Service over OTN NNI Indicates Test only WIKI: Needs Investigation. Wiki page isn't clear per Project Impacts. Xin Miao - ASAIK there is no SO change. Confirm with Henry Yu (Huawei). SUMMARY: Needs to confirm with Henry Yu There will likely be a Testing Effort (ELINE) |
| Control Loop | Wiki Page: Control Loop Sub Committee Frankfurt Release Planning Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact WIKI: Event based Common API for Control Loop Operations, scaleup/scaledown instantiation and PNF PNP. Event based Common Notification messaging format for Control Loop Operations APPC, SO, SDNC, VFC and SDNR to implement support of message and their flow from Policy SUMMARY: Seshu Kumar Mudiganti has no commitment. Potential Outage - Wiki Page indicates SO impact. |
| Multi Domain Optical Service L0/L1 Orchestration | Wiki Page: Multi-domain Optical Network Services Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact WIKI: Alignment (done): 3rd party ODM would change on 2 of BPMN. Need coordination. 3PODM post-poned (to R7) changed, thus only this MDOSL0L1O U/C will impact. Question: will refactoring affect this U/C? Answer: From Seshu: The refactoring is focused on PNF; thus it will NOT affect this U/C. BBS, VCPE & HPA will be affected. Question: Interaction with CCVPN use case and how will that affect your U/C? services not in place, have you talked to the CCVPN team; the extension doesn't have impact on SO in this release. This U/C is a SUB-use case of CCVPN. Detail alignment on resource modeling. CCVPN has a subU/C about e-line service orchestration. Thus alignment needs to happen between these two use cases. Code for CCVPN will be REUSED by this U/C, just make modification on those existing. Are you expecting SO interaction? Yes, the BPMN flows. Question: What are the two BPMN flows > the diagrams are in: Multi-domain Optical Network Services ; last time what you showed SO was a functional flow but not a BPMN change. Seshu wants to know the actual BPMN change. The two BPMN flow custom create end-to-end service instance. other is delete. Reuse these flows but to make some enhancements. there isn't a new or change in the W/F needed. We have to reuse existing flow and make model/configuration changes. SUMMARY: Can meet off-line with Xin Miao SO-2432 - Getting issue details... STATUS |
| CHANGE MANAGEMENT | Wiki Page: Change Management Frankfurt Extensions Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact WIKI:
Email from Lukasz Rajewski : "can you please add Change Management use case to the agenda, at least the items/REQ I am responsible for in Frankfurt: REQ-182, REQ-187, REQ-191" SUMMARY: Seshu Kumar Mudiganti had a discussion Architecture Meeting but need follow-up. |
| HPA | Wiki Page: Continuation of HPA Frankfurt Release Requirements: Indicates Test-Only WIKI: Unclear, Wiki needs work. SUMMARY: Test only. |
| RUN TIME SECURITY | Wiki Page: Run time Security using ISTIO - as a POC WIKI:
SUMMARY: Needs Investigation. Seshu Kumar Mudiganti is unaware of this change. contact Srinivasa Addepalli |
| K8S Based Cloud Region Support | Wiki Page: K8S based Cloud region support (Continue from R4) Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact Frankfurt Release Requirements : Indicates Test Only WIKI:
SUMMARY: Confirm Test only. Confirmed by Seshu. |
| DAaaS | Wiki Page: Distributed Analytics as a Service (Continuation from R4) Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Impact WIKI: Needs work. SUMMARY: Needs investigation. Seshu Kumar Mudiganti is not aware of this impact. |
| 3rd Party Operational Domain Manager | Wiki Page: Third-party Operational Domain Manager Use Case Spreadsheet: Indicates Test Only Frankfurt Release Requirements: Doesn't indicate anything WIKI:
SUMMARY: Impacts. Test only? Confirm. Need investigation. Only doing design time; run-time is not started. Contact Nishi Mathur (Telstra) |
PREDISCUSSION CALL (OCT 31 2019)
A prediscussion call for the Nov 6, 2019 U/C Realization call was help with Seshu to discuss the SO impacts for R6 Use Cases.
ATTENDEES
- Benjamin Cheung
- Xin Miao
- Oskar Malm
- Prabhu Balan
- Stavros Kanarakis
- Fei Zhang
- Seshu Kumar Mudiganti
- Timo Perala
SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION
| Document | File |
|---|---|
Use Case Realization Tracking Spreadsheet | |
| SO refactoring BPMN workflow (slides from Lukasz Grech) | |
Multi Domain Optical Services L0/L1 orchestration (link to ppt slides) - Xin Miao |
RECORDING for Pre-Meeting Oct 31, 2019
| Recording | FILE |
|---|---|
| Zoom Video & Audio (MP4) | |
| Audio Only (M4A) | |
| Playback (M3U) | |
| Chat (Txt) |
RECORDING for U/C Realization Nov 6, 2019
| Recording | FILE |
|---|---|
| Zoom Video & Audio (MP4) | |
| Audio Only (M4A) | |
| Playback (M3U) | |
| Chat (Txt) |