Versions Compared

Old Version 56

changes.mady.by.user Catherine Lefevre

Saved on

compared with

New Version 57

changes.mady.by.user Ranny Haiby

Saved on

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

  • Follow up on ASD Model Action Items
    • Work on 'definition" problem raised by Fernando Oliveira , Zu Qiang (Ericsson) , Marian Darula  + Thinh Nguyenphu.
      • Presentation by Marian Darula - <please upload deck here>
      • Reviewed the difference in approach between ASD and ETSI - ASD adds a "slim" descriptor that only fills the gaps of the Helm charts. The ETSI approach creates a full SOL001 IFA11 descriptors with the full set of attributes. The ETSI approach may lead to duplication of information and two separate entities trying to control the lifecycle of the CNF (orchestrator and K8S)
      • The ASD approach is using the IM of K8S/Helm
      • Fernando Oliveira - Contention point is about the variation between IM and implementation. The old ECOMP model or ETSI model is satisfactory,  there is no need for a new IM.
      • Zu Qiang (Ericsson) - Explains the xNF modeling with ASD
      • shitao li - There is no real duplication with the ETSI approach - Many of the attributes are  optional. The comparison of LCM approaches may not be accurate
      • Thinh Nguyenphu - In reality, it is not possible to use IFA11 to model a CNF.  Ericsson tried that in the last two releases and proved it cannot  be done. ONAP does not  have a general CNF IM. The ASD goal is to simplify the onboarding of CNFs, removing the need for VNFM
      • Thinh Nguyenphu - Proposes to respond to Fernando Oliveira 's comments
      • Chuyi Guo - It sounds like there is a need to continue the technical aspects in the modeling subcommittee. Proposes to use the upcoming meeting for this technical discussion.
      • Thinh Nguyenphu , Marian Darula - What is the point of continued discussion?
      • Catherine Lefevre - We need to move forward with implementation. Let's treat the ASD IM as v1, and work towards a v2 that will address the concerns of the modeling subcommittee.
      • AI  - Marian Darula - upload the existing ASD model as a v1
      • AI  - Catherine Lefevre - Will follow up in the TSC.
  • Presentation ONAP/EMCO Alignment prior LFN DDF
  • No meeting on Mar 15th - replaced by LFN CNF workshop

...