...
| Features/Capabilities | K8S Environment | CNTT/Arch Ref.2 | ONAP (Today) | ONAP CNCF | Comments | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CNF Scalability | From an Orchestration perspective: Cluster Autoscaler, HPA and VPA Handling within its own cluster From an Automation, Control Loop (CL) perspective | OOF, MSOSO, Multi-Cloud CL (DCAE, Policy, CLAMP + Triggered Action) | Adding value: Handling multiple K8S, Clusters | Not ONAP Scalability itself otherwise MUSIC, OOM (Container Orchestration) | ||
CNF Resiliency | From an Orchestration perspective: K8S Services From an Automation, Control Loop (CL) perspective | OOF, MSO, Multi-Cloud CL (DCAE, Policy, CLAMP + Triggered Action) | Not ONAP Resiliency itself otherwise MUSIC, OOM (Container Orchestration) | |||
| CNF Availability | Public Cloud is currently offering | 99<99.999 | Opportunity for ONAP | Not ONAP availability itself otherwise 99.9999+ built inside ONAP | ||
Secured service-to-service communication | - | Additional SW to be uploaded on top of K8S: Linkerd, ISTIO | AAF (VNFs only) | Integrate our ONAP Apps to Service Mesh  while keeping AAF as optionalAAF | Do we provide any certificate or shall we rely on a Certification Manager? | |
Logging | Stackdriver Logging Elasticsearch Fluentd | Logging/Pomba EELF/ELK | Centralization of Looging Logging - ONAP feature or external system to ONAP? | |||
Dashboard |
| Consul | ||||
Observability Events, Alarms, Analytics | Prometheus, Jaeger | DCAE | ||||
| Inventory | AAI | |||||
| Security | SECCOM | CNF Security Requirements |
Where are we on the CNCF Trail Journey?
...
- Canary Testing - Rolling upgrades
- Chaos Monkey Testing
- Performance
Pre-requisite(s)
- Is there any available CNF that we could use to prototype/test with "ONAP CNCF"?
- Check this link about CNF Testbed-https://github.com/cncf/cnf-testbed
- Check with OPNFV - if any investigation in this area
...
- Feedback from OVP PH2 meeting: https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/display/LN/2020-03-09+OVP+2.0+Meeting+notes
- Review of our previous feedback concerning Compliance & Verification Program - https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/display/LN/OVP+2.0+Boot+Strap
- 2 presentations:
- CNCF Compliance (Bill Mulligan) (PDF version)
- OVP Workstream (Rabi Abdel)
- Review "Features/Capabilities - How We complement each other?"
- Is there any impact on ONAP depending on CNF Deployment? New section is added
March 12th, 2020
- Feedback from OVP PH2 meeting: https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/display/LN/2020-03-09+OVP+2.0+Meeting+notes
- Review of our previous feedback concerning Compliance & Verification Program - https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/display/LN/OVP+2.0+Boot+Strap
- 2 presentations:
- CNCF Compliance (Bill Mulligan) (PDF version)
- OVP Workstream (Rabi Abdel)
- Do we need to extend our ONAP VNFReqs to consider CNF Reqs or shall we suggest a "LFN CNF Reqs" Board or will it be driven by CNCF?
- Need to connect with CNCF to avoid duplicated effort, divergence effort
- Suggestion to extend our VNFRqs team to represent our CNF needs to the CNCF
Action Items
- ONES CFP - Srinivasa Addepalli will work with Alla Goldner on the abstract - Key item - "the value that ONAP can bring"
- Kenny Paulset up doodle pole for meeting cadence and 2 or 3 per week
-
Sylvain Desbureaux - Start to work on our ONAP response to Dan (CNCF)
-
Try to identify where we are on the CNCF Trail Journey
-
Fill in the table - how we complement each other
-
Consolidation our message about ONAP Role - should be linked to our ONAP Respçonse to Dan (CNCF)
- Check with Kenny, David - how to record our upcomign discussions?
- Attend the next VNFReQs meeting and to discuss the extension of the team's scope - Trevor Lovett
- Follow-up with SECCOM about CNF Security reqs