Page History

...

• • There is general consensus within the modeling team for the proposal. General consensus includes:
    • All WIKI comments addressed (nothing left in discussion).
    • Call for team agreement in meeting for the email poll, and captured in meeting minutes.
  • The Modeling Chair does a “call for approval” of the wiki discussion page to onap-modelingsub@lists.onap.org, providing a 2-week time period for approval of the page. People respond “Yes”, "No" (with reasons) or “Abstain” (may with reasons). The goal of the poll is to gather opinions from the committee members.
  • In the following modeling subcommittee call after the end of the email poll, the Modeling Chair will address rough consensus of the poll:
    • If there's no objection received in the email poll and the modeling call, the contribution is approved.
    • If there are objections raised, the objectors shall describe their comments, and the team will see if the comments can be addressed and agreed. If so, the updated proposals will be reviewed and approved by email or in the following modeling calls.
    • If the objections cannot be addressed:
      • Option 1：a formal vote is conducted. Approval requires 2/3 of the votes approving the contribution, and the vote requires at least 3 companies to attend.
        • Note: the previous response in the poll will be considered as votes for from responding companies, unless they change their mind; and participants of the call can also attend the vote
      • Option 2：the chair will try to get rough consensus (reference: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7282), and the Modeling Chair will decide whether the contribution is approved based on the rough consensus
    • The Modeling Chair publishes the results to the mailing list, and record in meeting minutes. 
  • If approved, the DISCUSSION wiki goes to CLEAN. If not approved, there is no transition
  • If the subcommittee is unable to reach consensus (e.g., members have strong objections against the decisions), the subcommittee will escalate the matter to the TSC and seek guidance or decisions.

3. Wiki Comment Examples & Handling

...