Please put your @name in one of the option column and provide any comments you might have. Option 1 | Option 2 | Option 3 | Poll Comments |
---|
|
|
| Prefer to align with IFA names to ease the implementation | |
| Kevin Scaggs | - IFA is not consistent
- The turn-around time in IFA to make updates is slow
- We should not limit ourselves to just ETSI standard
- We should lead in setting standards, not just follow
- You may recall we earlier discussed that we would not follow and adhere to just one industry standard, but make use of whatever standard from whatever standard body that solved the issue at hand. Option 1 is in opposition to that approach.
|
|
| Arun Gupta | |
|
| Andy Mayer | We have an opportunity in ONAP to correct the inconsistencies in the IFA011 model and provide feedback to ETSI. We will ensure that we track any name changes and provide proper mapping back to the original IFA011 names. |
|
| Alexander Vul | Given our intent for a "best of breed" approach in the standards space, having our own conventions would be helpful.... |
|
| spolston | Best of breed approach where we advocate for our standards in ETSI and other bodies, but minimize constraints from their inconsistencies, and administrative processes. |
|
| |
|
|
| Brian Hedstrom | See my question below... | |
|
| Prefer to keep aligned with spec published names as the origin to avoid confusion for tracking and comparison. | maopeng zhang |
|
| Prefer to keep aligned with spec published names as the origin to avoid confusion for tracking and comparison. | Weitao Gao |
|
| Aligned with published spec names more friendly for developer. | |
|
| Keep consistent with IFA can help understand and avoid confusion | |
|
| Prefer to simplify the concepts to align with ETSIPerfer to use the ETSI naming convention to make concepts in the same page easily and avoid to create "new wheels" in the industry. For long term, we should have a mechanism to let ONAP and ETSI cooperate with each other. |
Priya TG Prefer aligning with ETSI to simplify and ease understanding of the IM |